Abortion: A Federalist Solution

Here's Radley Balko arguing for a federalist solution to the abortion debate:

While it's unlikely that the Founding Fathers anticipated the abortion debate, they did give us a framework around which to govern on issues just like it — highly emotional, high-stakes issues that go to the core of one's personal values and beliefs. They rightly recognized that the federal government is far too unwieldy and clumsy to deal with such delicate matters. These issues are best legislated by the states — or, better, by cities or counties. We can then choose to live under laws that most reflect our values. We vote with our feet...

The best solution is robust federalism. Forgo Roe, and let each state set its own policies on abortion. Those for whom abortion is an important fundamental right can live in areas where abortions are widely available. Those adamantly opposed to any and all abortions can live in jurisdictions that ban the procedure. People like me could live in communities where our tax dollars won't be funding abortions.

I think Balko is on to something.  If the last few decades have shown us anything, it's just how intractable the whole debate is, particularly since it is most passionately debated by the 'true believers' of both sides.  Here's Balko again:

Perhaps the most pertinent criticism of the federalist solution is that people with strong beliefs about an issue like abortion aren't content with applying those beliefs only to themselves and their immediate communities. Pro-lifers want it inscribed into federal law that life begins at conception, with no exceptions. Abortion-rights advocates want federal tax dollars to pay for abortions for the poor, despite the fact that some of those tax dollars come from citizens with moral objections to the procedure.

True believers, then, would never accept a federalist solution on a volatile issue like abortion. They'd rather impose their own values on everyone else. But after three decades of poisonous abortion politics, perhaps it's time the rest of us considered it.

Comments

[KipEsquire]

This was debated over at Catallarchy a while back. Balko's position is, as usual, totally untenable. If Roe were overturned, a federal Right To Life Act would be introduced in both chambers of Congress within 24 hours.

Balko's response is for the Supreme Court to "forbid" Congress to do so and "demand" a federalist approach.

My response at Catallarchy:

So [Balko is] advocating that the Supreme Court – without any precedential or theoretical basis – undertake a new jurisprudence of eviscerating the Fourteenth Amendment for the sake of reinvigorating the Tenth Amendment, thereby further elevating the fiction of "states rights" over individual rights?

Sorry, but that's not a particularly libertarian proposal.

[Jason Turner]

Kip...Thanks for your comments. I agree that Balko's proposal is not throughly libertarian, but in a polis of multiple interests a throughgoing, principled libertarianism, an all-or-nothing approach usually finds itself with nothing.

For me, Balko's proposal has the advantage of splitting the difference between the 'true believers' of both sides. As to how it would interfere with the fourteenth amendment, only those that believe all forms of abortion to be one of the immutable 'priveleges or immunities of citizens of the United States' would find Balko's proposal offensive. In other words, the idea that the right to abortion is a 'fundamental right or privilege' is exactly what is in question, with both sides finding the position of the other side reprehensible.

In many ways, Balko's proposal mirrors Jonathan Rauch's argument for a federalist approach to gay marriage: http://www.theatlantic.com/doc/prem/200404/rauch

Though I think that, realistically, you are correct. If the court were to overturn Roe, Congress would not let a day pass before issuing a federal ban on all abortion procedures. We'd then have to wait for the Court to rule that the issue is a state's right (10th amend) issue and that Congress does not have the power to prohibit.

[DUSTIN]

This is cool

[Buy Viagra]

Hi, I think your article its very important and interesting,good work, thanks for sharing!! Have a nice day!

[discount coach]

Just for today I will adjust myself to what is, and not try to adjust everything to my own desires. I will take my "luck" as it comes.

[pletcherjvp]

Un autre hommage chef de la http://www.chaussuresdefootballstore.com - nike mercurial vapor classique, http://www.chaussuresdefootballstore.com - mercurial vapor pas cher que le niveau ancestrale de leurs produits ont été aimés with Sneaker, depuis 2009, Hiroshi Fujiwara, qui, après le bung, l'afflux de personnes est devenu une forme d'arme en plein air. Cet automne, relancé http://www.chaussuresdefootballstore.com - mercurial vapor superfly chaussures, paragon upon owing the most division relationship à la première année de broadside, les lacets avec une boucle D-ring.

[Jimmy Choo Chaussures]

Nice, and thanks for sharing this info with us.Good Luck!

[broosyplertes]

Buy at some of these extremely super-cheap (Literally a minor fraction of the cost)!!!!!
Email me at buybreastactives @ gmail.com, so I can tell you how much. Please feel free to ask for any titles that are not on this listing.
(These are not all... there are about 25,000 whole titles availalble.)

Gilbert ''El Nino'' Melendez Career Pack (20 of 21 fights) :: Other Other
KFM Urban X Yellow Grade 16 week program :: XviD
UFC 103: Franklin vs Belfort - 10 Minute Preview :: XviD
PC build and repair2010-07-06 02:59:56 76
Braulio Estima - Invisible Jiu-Jitsu Volume 3 XviD/DivX
2010 03 19 The Fight Club 10 High Voltage XviD-JR XviD/DivX
Test Your C Skills2010-10-05 18:00:12 63
UFC 114 Post Fight Press Conference XviD-UPiNSMOKE XviD/DivX
UFC 91 High Definition Photos :: Other
1 WGP in Seoul] Hyun Man Myung vs Nae Chul Kim 2009-08-02 XviD/DivX
J K D Street Safe (Salvatore Oliva) :: MPEG
Strikeforce Fedor vs Henderson 2011 720p HDTV x264-aAF :: HDTV x264
Mike Fowler - Game Plan Seminar :: DVD XviD
UFC On FOX Cain vs JDS On-Sale Press Conference x264-R3lentless :: Web x264
UFC 109 Relentless SWEDiSH PDTV XviD-MaM XviD/DivX
Xing Yi - James McNeil - Five Elements TechniquesForm & Applications XviD/DivX
The Second post for Best And Most Expensive Fonts - Hurry!!!2006-11-25 15:56:45 264
UFC 104 - Kyle Kingsbury vs Razak Al-Hassan :: XviD
ESPN MMA Live-November 18th 2010 XviD-UPiNSMOKE :: XviD
Eddie Bravo - Mastering the Twister E-Book :: PDF
UFC Fight Night 07 19 08 DSRip XviD-aAF :: XviD
Internetwork Expert Routing and Switching COD 20102010-08-28 21:06:56 68
Barry Gibson's Train Hard, Fight Easy and Win! DIVX
Genki Sudo - Career Major Fights
The Elegant Universe - NOVA Series2010-12-26 18:34:47 51
Addison Wesley Problem Solving with C++ 7th Edition 20102010-11-14 21:24:31 57
The Official Corel Painter Magazine - vol 2 - Issue 13-24 + tutorial files)2010-11-22 16:35:43 56
K-1 World GP 2010 In Yokohama HDTV XviD-WB XviD/DivX
Hapkido KHF 1-2 Nam Je Kim (KOR) :: XviD
McGraw-Hill's LSAT, 2010 Edition Book Only)2009-08-24 17:30:16 121
Kettlebell Training for Wing Tsun Steve McMinn XviD/DivX
UFC 116 Lesnar vs Carwin PPV 720p HDTV x264-aAF :: HDTV x264
BJJ Seminars Year One by Roy Dean - XviD Version XviD/DivX
Evolution 14 - The Contenders Asia XviD/DivX
UFN 21 Nelson Vs Struve :: XviD
Aleksander Emelianenko Boxing Debut (03 10 2009) CAMrip :: XviD
Wing Chun White Crane Fist by Su, Ying Han :: MPEG
The Definitive Guide to GCC2010-09-19 10:41:39 65
Learning Spanish Like Crazy - Level 12011-07-10 09:34:54 23
UFC Fight Night (All events until September 2010) :: XviD
UFC 121 Martin Kampmann vs Jake Shiekds-a99223 WMV/ASF
Tattoo Secrets2009-06-01 07:45:49 133
8] Shinya Aoki vs Hayato Sakurai www kimjudas blogspot com x264
Vision Fighting Championship The Beginning SWEDiSH WS PDTV XviD-BOV :: PDTV XviD
League S-70 Team Sambo 70 vs Team Spain PDTV XviD-Lotto :: PDTV XviD
Shootboxing - 2010 02 13 - Ishin 2 - Xvid :: XviD
25 Natural Ways To Lower Blood Pressure2009-04-21 14:00:51 139
KOTC Greatest Submissions DSR Xvid-MaM XviD/DivX
Score Fighting Series-Casino Rama-Britto vs Young-Mein vs Burkman :: XviD
The Happiness Advantage-Shawn Achor2010-11-19 09:38:53 56

deal Bill Bryson - Short History of Nearly Everything2011-07-23 22:49:54 21 Lynda com - SQL Server 2008 Essential Training2011-05-19 06:37:38 31 Dream 14 720p HDTV x264-KYR :: HDTV x264 testimonial
buying Dream 13 HDTV XviD-WB XviD/DivX Inside MMA D6 Custom DVD ISO Read NFO DVD Deadliest Warrior S03E06 720p HDTV x264-aAF :: HDTV x264 review article
acquire Rings Lithuania - Bushido Rings 7: Adrenalinas - (Fedor, Yano) :: ISO Haye vs Valuev - Weigh-in XviD/DivX Name study
buy Enshin Karate - Sabaki Method :: MPEG Mirko CroCop" Filipovic Career <>3 Fights] :: XviD" Facebook Cookbook2009-05-30 06:53:35 133 discussion
order Bigger Muscles in 42 Days2006-11-21 14:38:54 265 Wiley - Mastering Microsoft Visual Basic 2010 RETAiL eBOOk-rebOOk2011-02-12 11:10:02 44 UFC Primetime Velasquez vs Dos Santos 720p x264-R3lentless :: Web x264 review
get hold of Paulo Filho vs Kazuo Misaki Pride - Bushido 13 XviD/DivX Wireless Crash Course, Second Edition2009-12-10 15:11:38 106 The Ultimate Fighter S10E05 720p HDTV x264-KYR :: HDTV x264 review article
deal Lynda com Acrobat 9 Professional Tips and Tricks-QUASAR2009-03-02 00:44:27 146 Commando Krav Maga - COMPLETE set2010-06-20 20:53:56 78 Walter VanHelder 29 Ne-Waza Techniques of Kodokan Judo DVDRip XviD-UPiNSMOKE :: DVD XviD report
look for Lynda com Joomla! 1 6 Beta Preview2010-10-26 00:30:24 60 Shooto Year End Show 2004 :: TV XviD The rear naked choke with pete spratt MPEG/xVCD guide
acquire DREAM 16 720p HDTV x264-RUDOS :: HDTV x264 joe franco - super strenght -requested- :: XviD Fighting Black Kings (1976) :: VHS XviD reviews
look for POLICE COMBAT TACTICS vol 2 DVD VTC - Crystal Reports XI: Beginner 2009-02-12 03:12:02 149 Ricky Hatton - A Life Story (21st July 2008) (XviD)] :: PDTV XviD rating
look for Satoshi Ishii- Road to UFC :: x264 VTC Intro to TCP IP2011-11-07 03:44:36 6 Bellator Fighting Championships XXX HDTV XviD-UPiNSMOKE XviD/DivX guide
order HDNet Inside MMA 12 04 09 720p HD TS--SRC Other The Book of Xen2009-12-14 19:02:55 105 Pancrase History #6 XviD/DivX review article
use Webinar - Knee Pain Considerations in Training & Rehab :: WMV TTC Audio - From Plato to Postmodernism2010-11-11 07:20:14 58 HDNet USA vs Japan 720p HD--SRC x264 read
use Mark Lutman - Introduction To Tohakure Ryu Ninjutsu Beg Level (DVD rip) :: XviD KRUSH 6 4/29/2010 DVD AJKF/K-1 affiliate DVD Four Weeks to a Better-Behaved Child : Breakthrough Discipline Techniques that Work2008-09-01 17:23:20 172 check out
find Fight Quest S01E08 Brazil XviD IceMan :: XviD Wyatt Woodsmall & Marilyne Woodsmall - The Future of Learning: The Michel Thomas Method2009-10-23 06:33:58 112 The Universe: The Complete Season Five2011-11-03 05:42:14 7 discussion
get Ultimate Challenge MMA UK 2010 Kings of the Cage WS PDTV XviD-BOV :: PDTV XviD Advances in Digital Forensics VI2011-03-05 22:57:29 41 ESPN MMA Live-January 14th 2011 XviD-UPiNSMOKE :: XviD assessment
find UFC 94 Lyoto Machida vs Thiago Silva SDRIP x264 x264 Masato 47 fights - bonus XviD/DivX Carol S Dweck - Mindset - The New Psychology of Success2010-10-07 09:47:10 63 assessment
acquire shooto brasil 10 :: XviD Demian Maia - Science of Jiu Jitsu 2 - Disc 2 BJJ Elite DVD > World Victory Road MMA-Tracker Official BigPack Vol 1 XviD/DivX read
deal Ruby on Rails For Dummies, Wiley Publishing 2007)2010-11-02 17:20:23 59 CMS Fundamentaals2011-04-07 19:51:21 37 UFC 103 - Trigg v Koscheck :: XviD evaluation
use 178 OllyDBG Cracking Tutorials2006-10-03 13:31:25 272 K-1 Scandinavia Rumble Of The Kings 2009 SWEDiSH DSR Xvid-MaM XviD/DivX LinuxCBT Enterprise Linux 5 Edition | Exclusive2008-06-24 14:05:34 182 discussion
find Shinya Aoki highlight by Damien WMV/ASF Roberto Spider Traven's Submissions & Sweeps DVDRip XviD-UPiNSMOKE XviD/DivX PrepLogic MegaGuides2011-02-15 16:20:34 44 synopsis
find Geometry - Berger2009-09-27 20:58:42 116 Name Knife Wound First Aid DVD article
buy UFC 107 Penn vs Sanchez Bonus NTSC DVDR-STOCK DVD Bellator Fighting Championships XXXI 720p HDTV x264-RUDOS :: HDTV x264 SkillSoft Basic Access 2007 Tables2009-03-12 01:07:07 145 reviews
purchase BRKSEC-2020: Firewall Design and Deployment2010-09-14 19:32:56 66 Essentials of Understanding Psychology2011-02-11 04:56:03 44 elasticsteel-everything you ever wanted to know about a side kick & hook kick DVD read
use UFC 126 Post Fight Press Conference WMV-SyM wmv :: WMV Kodokan Judo - Koshiki No Kata Antique Forms XviD/DivX Jon Jonny Bones Jones - Career Pack (13 Of 15 Fights) :: Mixed x264 article
pick up MMA Live UFC 108 Weigh-in Special Other Scientific American - February 20102010-01-27 02:43:26 99 Igor Yakimov Ultimate Leg Locks 6 DVDRiP (NEW) :: DVD Other overview
purchase How To Study - The 20 Step Guide2009-01-27 16:36:14 151 Duke Roufus: Muay Thai :: ISO UFC 88 Liddell vs Evans PPV HDTV XviD-aAF HDTV check out
acquire Bully Beatdown S03E03 Two Girls One Cage 720p MKV-sHoTV x264 Eddie Baran - Gymnastic Abs XviD/DivX BFC 31 Chris Lozano vs Yoshiyuki Yoshida XviD/DivX evaluation
get Alternative Energy Demystified2010-06-03 10:39:18 81 UFC Fight For The Troops 2 Preliminary Fights XviD-UPiNSMOKE :: XviD ElasticSteel MMA Training Series XviD/DivX reviewed
purchasing Bas Rutten - Superior Free Fight Techniques - Vol 5 :: MPEG Tony Horton - One on One - Vol 3 Disk 01 - Chest, Back & Balls DVD + avi DVD Fight Festival Goes Kaisaniemi Part II FiNNiSH XviD :: XviD check out
use 2009 BJJ Mundials Dics 2 - Womens Black Belt Finals x264 Project Management Case Studies2009-06-18 22:50:51 130 Best Of Gladiator Challenge 1] XviD-JR XviD/DivX testimony
use The Way of Shooto 3 - Matsune vs Sato :: XviD UFC•115•Chuck Liddell vs Rich Franklin•Full Event•720p•x264•BluntzRip :: x264 Fight Quest S01E06 France XviD IceMan XviD/DivX article
order when we left earth the nasa missions part 2 hdtv xvid-fqm2010-05-28 23:56:35 81 Sams Teach Yourself Drupal in 24 Hours2009-12-11 16:47:51 105 UFC 107 Penn vs Sanchez Bonus NTSC DVDR-STOCK DVD study

[lagedupija]

Rather than going with through the trial and error process of building up a good tool box for your woodworking and boat building project you can take a short cut by going to see a professional. There are others, mostly white male, like Dean Cain, Ben Cross (Chariots of Fire), Greg Evigan (BJ and the Bear), Robert Picardo (The Doctor of Star Trek Voyager) Corin Nemec (Stargate), Eric Balfour (Haven). This top layer allows you to see ahead and plan the future, which is something that no other animal can do. cypreses The loin which is composed of three divisions: the tenderloin used for filet mignon and porterhouse steaks. Do not leave them strewn all over your yard.